Mattress comparison

Classic Hybrid Extra-Firm vs Plank Firm Luxe

Looking for an alternative to the Plank Firm Luxe? Here is how it compares with the Classic Hybrid Extra-Firm.

Competitor details last checked · Source

The short version

Choose the Classic Hybrid Extra-Firm if

  • You want the more affordable mattress
  • You want a mattress made in Greenville, South Carolina, by a company making double-sided, flippable mattresses since the 1930s
  • You want a mattress its owners rate 4.9 out of 5 across more than 200 reviews

Choose the Plank Firm Luxe if

  • You want two firmness levels in one mattress: firm (7.5 to 8) on one side and ultra-firm (9.5 to 10) on the other
  • You want a longer trial: 365 nights against our 100
  • You want a longer warranty: limited lifetime against our 5 years

Side by side

Classic Hybrid Extra-Firm vs Plank Firm Luxe
Spec Engineered SleepClassic Hybrid Extra-Firm PlankFirm Luxe
Queen price $1,199 $1,599
Firmness 10 / 10 7.5–10 / 10 Flippable: firm side 7.5-8, ultra-firm side 9.5-10
Flippable (double-sided) Yes YesDifferent firmness on each side
Height 12 in 13 in
Construction Coil hybrid Coil hybrid
Made in Greenville, South Carolina Arizona, USA, with foreign and domestic components
Sleep trial 100 nights 365 nights
Warranty 5 years Limited lifetime
Shipping Free Free

Prices are regular Queen prices before discounts; both brands run sales. Firmness uses a 1-10 scale where 10 is firmest. Competitor details are from the brand's own website on the date shown above and may have changed.

Common questions

Is the Classic Hybrid Extra-Firm as firm as the Plank Firm Luxe?

We rate the Classic Hybrid Extra-Firm 10 out of 10. Plank rates the Firm Luxe 7.5 to 8 on its firm side and 9.5 to 10 on its ultra-firm side, so the Classic Hybrid Extra-Firm sits level with the firmer side of the Plank. Each brand rates its own mattresses, so treat the numbers as a guide.

Which is better if I want a very firm mattress?

Both are extra firm hybrid mattresses built on coils, made for people who like a hard, very firm feel. The Classic Hybrid Extra-Firm gives you one extra-firm feel at a lower regular price. The Plank Firm Luxe lets you flip between a firm side and an ultra-firm side.

Which is cheaper in a Queen?

At regular prices the Classic Hybrid Extra-Firm is $1,199 in a Queen and the Plank Firm Luxe is $1,599. Both brands run sales, so check current prices before you decide.

Can I flip either mattress?

Yes, both are double-sided. The Plank Firm Luxe has a different firmness on each side. The Classic Hybrid is a traditional double-sided, flippable mattress.

How do the sleep trial and warranty compare?

The Classic Hybrid comes with a 100-night sleep trial and a 5-year warranty. The Plank Firm Luxe comes with a 365-night trial and a limited lifetime warranty.

Made by Engineered Sleep

Classic Hybrid Extra-Firm

A 10 out of 10 extra-firm hybrid that is more affordable than the Plank Firm Luxe.

From $854.10 · 4.9/5 from 226 reviews